We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page.



Photos: Lodge, All-Clad, Made In
The safest skillets skip coatings altogether. Our top pick is the Lodge Classic 10.25-inch cast iron skillet, which costs about $25 and is made in the U.S. The Field Company No. 8 is a lighter, smoother cast iron pan worth the splurge. The All-Clad D3 is our stainless steel pick, Made In's carbon steel pan heats fast like stainless and seasons like cast iron, and Xtrema makes a pan that's 100% ceramic.
How we vetted these picks
✓ No PTFE or other PFAS coatings. We skipped "ceramic nonstick" coated pans too, since the coating wears off.
✓ Every pick says exactly what touches your food.
✓ We didn't lab-test. Picks rely on maker and retailer specs, owner reviews and published research.
Our picks

OUR PICK
Lodge Classic 10.25" Cast Iron Skillet
Cheap, nearly indestructible and made in the U.S. It gets more nonstick the more you cook in it.
Touches your food: cast iron, seasoned with vegetable oil

UPGRADE PICK
Field Company No. 8 Skillet
Lighter than Lodge, with a smooth, machined cooking surface, and cast in the U.S. from recycled iron.
Touches your food: cast iron, seasoned with grapeseed oil

BEST STAINLESS STEEL
All-Clad D3 10" Fry Pan with Lid
The tri-ply pan most pro cooks learned on. It sears hard, goes in the dishwasher and lasts for decades.
Touches your food: stainless steel

BEST CARBON STEEL
Made In Seasoned Carbon Steel 10"
Half the weight of cast iron, heats fast and arrives pre-seasoned. Made in Sweden.
Touches your food: carbon steel, seasoned with plant oils

BEST 100% CERAMIC
Xtrema Versa Pan 10"
Solid ceramic all the way through, with no metal and no coating, and third-party tested for lead and cadmium.
Touches your food: glazed ceramic
Why your skillet matters
Your skillet is probably the hardest-working pan you own. It goes on high heat most days, gets scraped with spatulas and scrubbed after every meal. If it's nonstick, that coating is almost always PTFE, the Teflon-family material that belongs to the PFAS "forever chemical" group.
Coatings shed as they wear. Researchers at the University of Newcastle in Australia estimated that a single scratch in a nonstick surface can release about 9,100 particles during cooking, and a badly damaged area about 2.3 million, FOX 5 reported.
High heat is the other problem. PTFE starts to break down at about 500°F, and fumes can be released above that, according to Poison Control. Preheating an empty pan on high, a common habit with skillets, is the quickest way to get there.
Who's regulating nonstick pans?
Mostly the states. "In the absence of comprehensive federal regulation of PFAS in cookware, states are enacting and proposing their own laws," the law firm Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner wrote. Minnesota banned cookware with intentionally added PFAS in 2025, and Colorado followed in January 2026.
Families shouldn't have to wait for Washington to sort this out. Pans without coatings have been around for more than a century, and most of them cost less than a nonstick set.
Which material is right for you?
Cast iron is cheap, holds heat for great searing and builds a natural nonstick layer as you cook. It's heavy, and it needs drying and a little oil after washing.
Carbon steel seasons like cast iron but is thinner and lighter, so it heats faster. It's the classic choice for eggs and stir-fries.
Stainless steel needs no seasoning and goes in the dishwasher. Food sticks unless you preheat well and use enough fat.
100% ceramic has no metal at all and works in the oven and microwave. It's heavy, can crack if dropped, and doesn't work on induction without an adapter.
How we chose
No coatings. We left out PTFE nonstick and ceramic-coated pans.
Clear materials from the maker, including the seasoning oil on cast iron and carbon steel.
Everyday size. A 10- to 10.25-inch pan fits two eggs or a pair of chicken thighs.
Long life. Each pick should last decades with basic care.
We didn't lab-test these pans. Our picks rely on manufacturer and retailer specs, owner reviews and published research.
The best non-toxic skillets
OUR PICK
Lodge Classic 10.25" Cast Iron Skillet

Photo: Lodge
What touches your food: Cast iron with a factory seasoning of soy-based vegetable oil. There's no synthetic coating.
Why we picked it: It's the best value in cookware. The 10.25-inch size was $24.90 on Lodge's site when we checked, down from $29.95, and it works on any stovetop, in the oven, on the grill or over a campfire. Lodge has made cast iron in South Pittsburg, Tennessee, since 1896.
Things to know:
It's heavy, at about 5 pounds, and the handle gets hot.
The surface is pebbly out of the box. It gets smoother and more nonstick with use.
Dry it right after washing and wipe on a thin layer of oil, or it can rust.
Best for: Anyone replacing a nonstick pan on a budget.
UPGRADE PICK
Field Company No. 8 Skillet

Photo: Field Company
What touches your food: Cast iron made from recycled U.S. iron, pre-seasoned with several coats of grapeseed oil.
Why we picked it: It's cast iron that's easier to live with. The No. 8 measures 10.25 inches across and weighs 4.3 pounds, about a pound less than Lodge's, and its smooth surface releases eggs sooner. It was $165 when we checked. Smithey's No. 10 is a similar, polished alternative.
Things to know:
The cooking surface is 8.75 inches, smaller than the rim suggests.
It needs the same dry-and-oil care as any cast iron.
Best for: A gift, or anyone who finds Lodge too heavy.
BEST STAINLESS STEEL
All-Clad D3 10" Fry Pan with Lid

Photo: All-Clad
What touches your food: Stainless steel, bonded over an aluminum core that never touches food.
Why we picked it: Tri-ply stainless heats evenly, browns well and needs no seasoning. It's oven and broiler safe to 600°F, and it's bonded and assembled in Canonsburg, Pennsylvania, with some global components. It was $139.99 on sale, down from $169.99, when we checked.
Things to know:
Eggs and fish stick unless you preheat the pan and add enough fat.
New stainless steel can release small amounts of nickel and chromium into acidic foods simmered for hours, an Oregon State University study found, and that drops with use. People with a nickel allergy may prefer cast iron or ceramic for long-cooked tomato sauce.
Best for: Searing, pan sauces and anyone who wants to use the dishwasher.
BEST CARBON STEEL
Made In Seasoned Carbon Steel 10"

Photo: Made In
What touches your food: Carbon steel, pre-seasoned with shea nut and coconut oil. Made In says its carbon steel is made without PFAS, PTFE, lead or cadmium.
Why we picked it: Carbon steel is what many restaurant line cooks use for eggs. It's thinner than cast iron, so it heats and cools quickly, and this one comes seasoned so you can cook right away. It's made in Sweden and was $119 for the 10-inch size when we checked.
Things to know:
Hand wash only. Like cast iron, it rusts if left wet.
The seasoning can look blotchy at first. That's normal and evens out with use.
Skip long-simmered acidic sauces, which strip seasoning from thin steel.
Best for: Eggs, stir-fries and cooks who want nonstick without a coating.
BEST 100% CERAMIC
Xtrema Versa Pan 10"

Photo: Xtrema
What touches your food: Ceramic made from clay and minerals with a silica-based glaze fused on during firing. Xtrema says an independent lab, SGS, tests its products for lead and cadmium to California's Prop 65 standard.
Why we picked it: It's the only pick with no metal at all. The pan is one solid piece of ceramic with a ceramic lid, and it goes from stovetop to oven to microwave to dishwasher. The 10-inch size was $150.50 when we checked.
Things to know:
It's heavy and can crack or chip if dropped. Store it so it doesn't knock against other pans.
Heat it on low to medium and add oil before cooking. It won't work on induction without an adapter disc.
It's shaped more like a shallow sauté pan than a classic flared skillet.
Best for: Households that want no metal touching food.
What to avoid in a skillet
PTFE nonstick, including pans sold as "granite," "stone" or "diamond." Those names describe a look or an additive, and many still use a PTFE base.
"PFOA-free" stickers. PFOA was phased out of U.S. production years ago, so the label tells you little about the coating itself.
Ceramic-coated pans as a forever pan. They skip PTFE, but the thin coating wears off, often within a few years. Treat them as a middle option, not a pick.
Unbranded imported aluminum cookware, which the FDA warned in 2025 can leach lead.
Scratched or flaking nonstick. If you still use a coated pan, retire it once the surface is damaged.
How to keep food from sticking
Preheat first. Heat the pan over medium for a few minutes before adding oil. In stainless steel, a drop of water should skate around the pan in beads.
Use enough fat, and let it shimmer before the food goes in.
Wait for the release. Meat and eggs stick at first, then let go once they've browned. Don't force them.
Season as you go. For cast iron and carbon steel, wipe on a thin coat of oil after each wash and warm the pan until it's dry.
FAQs
What is the least toxic frying pan?
Uncoated pans: cast iron, carbon steel, tri-ply stainless steel or 100% ceramic. None of them has a PTFE nonstick coating to wear off.
Is cast iron safe to cook with?
Yes. Cast iron adds small amounts of iron to food, more with acidic dishes. That's fine for most people, but people with hemochromatosis or iron overload should ask their doctor.
Is stainless steel cookware safe?
Stainless steel has no coating. New stainless pans can release small amounts of nickel and chromium into acidic foods cooked for hours, and that drops with use. People with a nickel allergy may prefer cast iron or ceramic for long-simmered tomato dishes.
Is ceramic nonstick cookware non-toxic?
Ceramic-coated pans don't use PTFE, but the coating wears off over time. A pan that's 100% ceramic, with no metal core and no coating, avoids that problem.
The bottom line
Your skillet sees more heat and scraping than any other pan, so it's the first one to swap out of nonstick.
A $25 Lodge cast iron skillet is the easiest place to start.
Pick carbon steel for eggs, stainless for searing and the dishwasher, or 100% ceramic for no metal at all.
Ignore "PFOA-free" labels. Look for pans with no coating at all.
More from Healthy Again
Sources
Healthy, Again. is health news, not medical advice. Talk to your doctor before changing any medicine or supplement.