We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page.

Pyrex Easy Grab glass baking dish
Emile Henry ceramic pie dish
Nordic Ware uncoated aluminum half sheet
Photos: Pyrex, Emile Henry, Nordic Ware

The cleanest bakeware has no coating at all: glass, glazed stoneware, stainless steel or plain uncoated aluminum, with unbleached parchment paper instead of nonstick. Our picks are a Pyrex glass dish for casseroles, an Emile Henry pie dish, TeamFar stainless steel sheet pans and Nordic Ware's uncoated aluminum half sheet for cookies.

How we vetted these picks

✓ No coating where possible. Glass, glazed clay, stainless steel and bare aluminum come first.

✓ Every pick says exactly what touches your food.

✓ We didn't lab-test. Picks rely on maker specs, owner reviews and published research.

Our picks

Pyrex Easy Grab 3-quart glass baking dish
OUR PICK FOR CASSEROLES

Pyrex Easy Grab 3-quart glass baking dish

Glass has nothing to coat, peel or leach, and the 9-by-13 size handles every casserole on the table.

Touches your food: tempered glass

Emile Henry ceramic pie dish
OUR PICK FOR PIES

Emile Henry pie dish

Made in France with a glaze the company says is lead- and cadmium-free, and backed by a 10-year guarantee.

Touches your food: glazed high-fire clay

TeamFar stainless steel baking sheets
OUR PICK FOR STAINLESS SHEET PANS

TeamFar stainless steel baking sheets, set of 2

An inexpensive way to get uncoated steel sheet pans, for readers who'd rather skip aluminum.

Touches your food: 18/0 stainless steel

Nordic Ware Naturals Baker's Half Sheet
OUR PICK FOR COOKIES

Nordic Ware Naturals Baker's Half Sheet

Bare aluminum spreads heat evenly, so cookies brown evenly, and there's no coating to wear off.

Touches your food: uncoated aluminum

USA Pan half sheet pan
IF YOU WANT NONSTICK

USA Pan half sheet

The cleanest nonstick option we found: a silicone coating the company says is made without PTFE, PFOA and BPA.

Touches your food: silicone coating over aluminized steel

If You Care unbleached parchment baking paper
ESSENTIAL ADD-ON

If You Care parchment baking paper

Parchment is what makes uncoated pans practical. Unbleached, chlorine-free and rated to 428°F.

Touches your food: unbleached paper with a silicone coating

What's wrong with nonstick bakeware?

Most dark nonstick sheet pans, muffin tins, loaf pans and cake pans are coated with PTFE, the Teflon-family material that's part of the PFAS "forever chemical" group.

Coatings wear. Metal spatulas, scrubbing and years of use scratch them. Researchers at the University of Newcastle in Australia estimated that a single scratch in a nonstick surface can release about 9,100 particles during cooking, and a badly damaged area about 2.3 million, FOX 5 reported.

High heat matters. PTFE starts to break down at about 500°F, according to Poison Control. Most baking happens at 350°F, but roasting vegetables at 450°F or finishing a dish under the broiler gets close.

The rules are coming from the states, not Washington. Minnesota banned cookware and bakeware with intentionally added PFAS in 2025, and Colorado followed in January 2026, according to the law firm Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner. The MAHA Commission's 2025 assessment called for more study of PFAS and children's health, according to Beveridge & Diamond, but stopped short of new limits.

Holiday baking is when kids are in the kitchen, licking spoons and eating cookies off the tray. Our grandparents baked in glass, stoneware, steel and enamel. Those materials still work.

How we chose

  • No coating where possible. Glass, glazed clay, stainless steel and bare aluminum come first. We include one silicone-coated pan, clearly labeled, for readers who want release without PTFE.

  • Clear materials. The maker or seller has to say what the pan is made of, and for glazes, whether they contain lead or cadmium.

  • Performance. A pan you won't use doesn't help anyone.

We didn't lab-test this bakeware. Our picks rely on manufacturer and retailer specs, owner reviews and published research.

The best non-toxic bakeware

OUR PICK FOR CASSEROLES

Pyrex Easy Grab 3-quart glass baking dish

Pyrex Easy Grab 3-quart glass baking dish

Photo: Pyrex

What touches your food: Tempered glass. The lid is BPA-free plastic.

Why we picked it: Glass has nothing to coat, peel or leach, and this 9-by-13 size handles stuffing, green bean casserole and sweet potatoes. It was $15.99 when we checked.

Things to know:

  • Pyrex lists the plastic lid as safe for the dishwasher, freezer and microwave, but not the oven. Take it off before baking, and don't store hot food under it.

  • Pyrex sold in the U.S. is generally soda-lime glass, while European PYREX is borosilicate, which handles sudden temperature changes better, Hackaday explained. Don't move a hot dish onto a wet counter or add cold liquid to it.

Best for: Every casserole on the Thanksgiving table.

OUR PICK FOR PIES

Emile Henry pie dish

Emile Henry ceramic pie dish

Photo: Emile Henry

What touches your food: A glazed, high-fire Burgundy clay dish. The company says its glaze is lead- and cadmium-free.

Why we picked it: Glazed ceramic is a good choice for pies when the maker addresses lead, and Emile Henry does. The dishes are made in France and carry a 10-year guarantee against production faults.

Things to know:

  • It costs more than glass, and the 9-inch dish was sold out on the company's U.S. site when we checked.

  • Ceramic can crack if dropped.

Best for: Pumpkin pie, apple pie and quiche.

OUR PICK FOR STAINLESS SHEET PANS

TeamFar stainless steel baking sheets

TeamFar uncoated stainless steel baking sheets, set of two

Photo: TeamFar

What touches your food: 18/0 stainless steel with no coating.

Why we picked it: It's an inexpensive way to get uncoated steel sheet pans, and they're dishwasher safe. They come as a set of two in a 17.6-by-13-inch size, about the same as a standard half sheet. A set was listed at $24.99 when we checked.

Things to know:

  • Stainless steel conducts heat less evenly than aluminum, so cookies may brown less evenly on the bottom.

  • Food sticks more without parchment.

Best for: Roasted vegetables and sheet-pan dinners, especially for readers avoiding aluminum.

OUR PICK FOR COOKIES

Nordic Ware Naturals Baker's Half Sheet

Nordic Ware Naturals Baker's Half Sheet uncoated aluminum sheet pan

Photo: Nordic Ware

What touches your food: Pure, uncoated aluminum, with a steel rim sealed inside the edge.

Why we picked it: Bare aluminum spreads heat evenly, so cookies brown evenly, and there's no coating. It's made in the U.S. from domestic and imported materials and was listed at $20 when we checked.

Things to know:

  • Nordic Ware itself warns that acidic foods like tomatoes and vinegar can darken or pit the pan, so line it with parchment for anything acidic.

  • It should be washed by hand. Some readers avoid bare aluminum altogether. If that's you, choose stainless steel.

Best for: Cookies, biscuits and anything you want golden on the bottom.

IF YOU WANT NONSTICK

USA Pan half sheet

USA Pan half sheet pan with Americoat silicone coating

Photo: USA Pan

What touches your food: Aluminized steel with USA Pan's Americoat silicone coating, which the company says is made without PTFE, PFOA and BPA.

Why we picked it: If you want easy release without PTFE, this is the cleanest nonstick option we found. It's made in the USA and was $26.99 at Abt when we checked.

Things to know:

  • It's still a coating, and like any coating it can wear. We'd pick uncoated steel, glass or aluminum first.

Best for: Bakers who aren't ready to give up nonstick.

ESSENTIAL ADD-ON

If You Care parchment baking paper

If You Care unbleached parchment baking paper roll

Photo: If You Care

What touches your food: Unbleached, totally chlorine-free paper with a silicone coating. The brand says it's free of Quilon, a chromium-based coating used on some release papers.

Why we picked it: Parchment is what makes uncoated pans practical. It keeps cookies from sticking to steel and keeps acidic food off aluminum. It's rated to 428°F and was $4.39 on sale at Target when we checked.

Things to know:

  • It's single-use, and you shouldn't use it above 428°F or under the broiler.

Best for: Every pan in this guide.

What to avoid in bakeware

  • Dark nonstick pans with no material listed. They're almost always PTFE.

  • "PFOA-free" on its own. It doesn't mean PFAS-free. Our rice cooker guide explains why.

  • Vintage or unbranded glazed ceramics with no lead or cadmium information.

  • Scratched or flaking coated pans. Replace them.

  • Plastic lids in the oven, and storing hot leftovers under them.

How to bake without nonstick

  • Line pans with parchment for cookies, roasted vegetables and anything sticky or acidic.

  • Grease with butter or oil and a dusting of flour for cakes and loaves.

  • Let baked goods cool for a few minutes before lifting them. They release more easily.

  • Soak, don't scour. Hot water and baking soda loosen stuck-on bits on steel and glass.

FAQs

Is nonstick bakeware safe?

Most nonstick bakeware uses PTFE, a PFAS. PTFE begins to break down at about 500°F, and coatings shed particles as they wear. Glass, stainless steel and uncoated aluminum avoid both problems.

Is ceramic-coated bakeware safe?

Ceramic coatings are PFAS-free, which is better than PTFE. But they're still a coating that wears with use. If you want nonstick, choose a coating made without PTFE and replace it when it wears.

Is aluminum bakeware safe?

Uncoated aluminum has no PFAS. It can react with acidic foods, which is why Nordic Ware recommends against baking them directly on its pans. Lining aluminum with parchment avoids the contact. Readers who'd rather skip aluminum can choose stainless steel or glass.

Is glass bakeware safe?

Yes. Glass has no coating and doesn't react with food. Avoid sudden temperature changes, and keep plastic lids out of the oven.

Is silicone bakeware safe?

Silicone is PFAS-free and widely used, but there's less long-term research on it than on glass or steel. We prefer uncoated pans plus parchment.

The bottom line

  • Most nonstick bakeware is coated with PTFE, a PFAS. Coatings wear, and PTFE breaks down at high heat.

  • Glass, glazed stoneware with lead-free glaze, stainless steel and plain aluminum need no coating.

  • Unbleached parchment paper makes uncoated pans work for almost anything.

  • If you want nonstick, choose a coating made without PTFE and treat it gently.

More from Healthy Again

Sources

Healthy, Again. is health news, not medical advice. Talk to your doctor before changing any medicine or supplement.