We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page.



Photos: Made In, Cuisinart, Granite Ware
Before the roasting pan comes down from the top shelf this year, turn the rack over and take a close look. If it's dark gray and slick, or if thin silver lines show through where it's been scrubbed, it's coated. In two weeks it will spend three to five hours under a 15-pound bird, sitting in fat and pan juices that you'll turn into gravy.
Americans were expected to eat nearly 30 million turkeys last Thanksgiving, the National Turkey Federation estimated. Most of them roast in a pan that comes out once a year, so few of us think about what it's made of. Many roasters on store shelves have a nonstick coating, usually PTFE, the Teflon-family chemical that belongs to the PFAS "forever chemical" group. Even some expensive stainless steel roasters ship with a coated rack, and the listing doesn't always make that obvious.
We'll be straight about the risk. At a standard 325°F, a nonstick pan is well below the temperature where PTFE starts to break down. The bigger concerns are a scratched coating shedding particles into the drippings, recipes that start hot or finish under the broiler, and what it takes to make these coatings in the first place. In North Carolina, a chemical produced at a plant that makes Teflon-related compounds turned up in the drinking water of hundreds of thousands of people, and Washington is now moving to drop the federal limit on it.
The good news: a roaster with nothing on it costs as little as $46 and lasts for decades. Here's what's on a typical roasting pan, the plastic and foil that usually go into the oven with it, what the rules do and don't cover, and the five roasters we'd actually buy.
How we reported this guide
✓ We read the research behind every claim, from Poison Control's guidance on overheated nonstick pans to studies of what foil, nylon and hot plastic release into food.
✓ We checked every pick's materials against the maker's or retailer's own listing, including the rack, which is where coatings hide.
✓ We didn't lab-test. Our picks rely on maker and retailer specs, owner reviews and published research, and we say what each maker doesn't disclose.
Table of Contents
Our picks
Best overall: Made In Stainless Clad Roasting Pan ($164.99, down from $199). Three-ply stainless steel, a stainless rack and room for a 24-pound turkey.
Best value: Cuisinart MultiClad Pro 16" ($119.95 on sale at Crate & Barrel). The same clad build for less, with a solid stainless rack.
Budget pick: Cuisinart Chef's Classic 16" ($79.99 on sale at Kohl's). Plain stainless steel with a stainless rack.
Cheapest: Granite Ware 19" Covered Oval Roaster ($45.99 at Target). Porcelain enamel on steel, sized for a bird up to 20 pounds, with a lid.
If you want a nonstick pan: Caraway Roasting Pan. A ceramic coating made without PTFE and a stainless rack, for families who won't give up easy cleanup.
Why your roasting pan matters more than most pans
Most pans hold food for 10 or 20 minutes. A roasting pan holds a turkey for hours. The USDA says to roast a whole turkey in an oven set no lower than 325°F. At that temperature, a 16- to 18-pound bird takes about 3¼ to 4 hours, and an 18- to 20-pound bird about 3½ to 4¼ hours, according to Williams-Sonoma's roasting chart.
The conditions in that pan are the ones that pull the most out of cookware: heat, fat, salt and acid. Drippings are mostly fat and salty juices, and many recipes add wine, cider or citrus. In lab tests of foil-wrapped meat, for example, the amount of metal that moved into the food rose with fat content, acidity and cooking temperature. Roasting racks also take a beating. They're scraped, soaked and scrubbed once a year, then stored for 11 months.
Then the drippings become gravy. Whatever comes off the pan doesn't stay on the pan. It ends up in the gravy boat.

What's actually on a nonstick roasting pan?
PTFE, a "forever chemical"
Most nonstick roasters are coated with polytetrafluoroethylene, or PTFE, the slick polymer best known as Teflon. It belongs to the PFAS family, thousands of "forever chemicals" that break down so slowly they build up in the environment and in people. Our PFAS explainer covers what the research links them to.
PTFE is stable at ordinary cooking temperatures. It starts to break down at temperatures above about 500°F, according to Poison Control, and the fumes can cause polymer fume fever, or "Teflon flu": chills, fever, headache and body aches that usually clear in a day or two. U.S. poison centers logged only a few hundred cases in 2023, and Poison Control says the true number is likely higher because the symptoms look like a cold. Pet birds are far more sensitive. For them, sudden death can be the first sign, which is why Poison Control advises keeping birds out of the kitchen.
Poison Control's advice lines up with Thanksgiving's riskiest moves: don't preheat an empty nonstick pan, and skip high heat and broiling in nonstick pans. Plenty of turkey recipes start in a 425°F or 450°F oven, or finish under the broiler to crisp the skin. If yours does, that's a good reason to roast in plain steel or enamel.
Scratches shed particles
Coatings wear, and when they wear, they shed. Researchers at the University of Newcastle in Australia estimated that a single scratch on a nonstick surface can release about 9,100 plastic particles during cooking, and a badly damaged area about 2.3 million, FOX 5 reported. A roasting rack, all wires and welds, is about the hardest nonstick surface there is to clean gently.
"PFOA-free" tells you almost nothing
Many roasters advertise "PFOA-free." PFOA is a chemical that was once used to make PTFE. In 2006, the EPA invited the eight major companies in the industry to phase it out of their emissions and products, and all of them state that they met the program's goals by 2015. So nearly any nonstick pan made in the last decade is PFOA-free, and still coated in PTFE. We explain more in our rice cooker guide.
Ceramic coatings are a different trade-off
"Ceramic" nonstick coatings, like Caraway's, are made without PTFE. Caraway says its roasting pan's coating is free of PTFE, PFOA, PFAS, lead and cadmium. For a pan that sits in the oven for hours, that's a real improvement over PTFE. The catch is durability. Coatings of every kind wear out, and manufacturers generally recommend replacing coated cookware every two to five years, or once the coating starts to peel, The New York Times reported.
Marketing words deserve skepticism, too. In 2025, HexClad agreed to a $2.5 million class-action settlement over claims that it marketed cookware as "non-toxic" and PFAS-free while its nonstick coating contained PTFE. HexClad denied wrongdoing but agreed to stop calling products that contain PTFE "non-toxic," "PFOA free" or "PFAS free."
The rack problem: a stainless pan with a coated rack
A stainless steel roaster isn't always fully stainless. Racks are often sold with a nonstick coating, and the listing may not make that obvious.
All-Clad's Gourmet Accessories Large Stainless Steel Roaster is one example. Its pan is 18/10 stainless steel, but the product page notes that it "contains PTFE for its nonstick properties," and while the pan is rated to 600°F, the rack is rated only to 375°F. That lower limit is a common sign of a coated rack.

Before you buy: look for the words "stainless steel rack" or "solid stainless rack." If the rack has its own, lower temperature limit, assume it's coated. If the listing doesn't say what the rack is made of, ask the seller before you order.
What size roasting pan do you need for your turkey?
Too small and the bird hangs over the edge, juices spill and the thighs cook unevenly. Too big and the drippings spread thin and scorch. Home roasting pans usually come in 14-, 16- and 18-inch sizes, measured across the width, according to Made In. Here's a rough guide, based on Made In's sizing guide and Williams-Sonoma's minimum pan sizes:
Turkey weight | Pan size | Our picks that fit |
|---|---|---|
Up to 12 pounds | 14-inch (about 14 x 10 inches) | Any of our picks |
Up to 16 pounds | 16-inch (about 16 x 12 inches) | Cuisinart Chef's Classic, Cuisinart MultiClad Pro, Caraway, Granite Ware 19" with the lid on |
16 to 20 pounds | A large 16-inch (16 x 13 inches) or an 18-inch | Cuisinart MultiClad Pro, Caraway, Granite Ware 19" with the lid off, Made In |
20 to 24 pounds | 18-inch (about 18 x 13 inches) | Made In |
Two more things to check. First, your oven: measure the inside before you buy an 18-inch pan, and leave room around it so heat can circulate. Second, the depth. The USDA notes that the depth and size of the pan can reduce heat circulation to the turkey, and a pan that's too big for the oven can block it. It recommends roasting on a rack in a shallow pan.

The plastic and foil that go in the oven with your turkey
A coating-free pan is the biggest fix, but it isn't the only thing touching your turkey. A lot of Thanksgiving cooking happens in plastic and foil, much of it hot. Here's what the research says about each, and what to use instead.

Oven bags
Oven bags keep a bird moist and save on cleanup. Reynolds says its bags are made of an FDA-compliant, heat-resistant nylon and should never go above 400°F. Nylon is a type of polyamide plastic. In 2019, Germany's Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR) found that small molecules called oligomers migrate from polyamide kitchen utensils into food, and in 10 of the 33 utensils it reviewed, the amount exceeded the level it considers acceptable. The BfR advised keeping polyamide's contact with hot food, above 70°C or 158°F, as brief as possible.
That research looked at spoons and spatulas, not oven bags, and we couldn't find a published study of turkey bags. But a bag holds a bird well above 158°F for hours. If you want moist meat without the plastic, use a roaster with a lid. The USDA notes that a lid speeds cooking, and our cheapest pick comes with one.
Aluminum foil
Foil is aluminum, and aluminum moves into food during cooking. In a 2018 study in the Journal of Food Processing and Preservation, researchers at Hacettepe University in Turkey baked beef, mutton and chicken wrapped in foil and found aluminum in the meat rose up to about 12 times background levels. Leaching increased with fat content, acidity and cooking temperature, and a foil lined with baking paper on the food side cut migration in about half of the comparisons.
A turkey checks every box: fatty, salty, often basted with wine or citrus, and in the oven for hours. The fixes are easy. Tent the breast with parchment, or put a sheet of parchment between the bird and the foil. Use a lid instead of a foil cover. Keep foil away from acidic glazes. And don't leave a foil tent on for the whole roast; the USDA notes that doing so slows cooking.
Disposable aluminum pans
The thin foil roaster from the grocery store is the same aluminum, sitting in the same salty, acidic drippings, with a buckling problem added. Williams-Sonoma's turkey guide advises doubling foil pans for strength and taking special care moving them in and out of the oven. If you host every year, a $46 enamel roaster will outlast decades of disposable ones.
Brining bags and containers
The USDA says to brine in a food-grade plastic, stainless steel or glass container, or a food-grade plastic bag, never a trash bag, with the bird fully submerged and kept in the refrigerator or a cooler with ice.
Cold matters for more than food safety. With plastic, heat is what drives shedding. In a 2020 study in Nature Food, researchers at Trinity College Dublin found that polypropylene baby bottles released about 600,000 microplastic particles per liter of 25°C water and about 55 million per liter at 95°C. A cold brine in a food-grade bag is a far smaller concern than hot food in plastic. If you'd rather skip plastic altogether, brine in a stainless steel stockpot, or dry-brine: salt the bird and let it rest uncovered on a rack in the refrigerator.
Gravy separators, basters and carving boards
The hottest plastic of the day is often the gravy separator, filled with near-boiling drippings, and many are plastic. Given what heat does to plastic, a glass measuring cup works just as well: let the drippings settle for a few minutes and spoon the fat off the top. The same logic applies to plastic bulb basters, which pull up hot fat over and over; a long stainless steel spoon does the job. And carve on wood, not plastic. Our cutting board guide explains why.
How to read a roasting pan listing in 30 seconds
Look for "stainless steel rack" or "solid stainless rack." If the rack's material isn't listed, ask.
Check for a second temperature limit. If the rack is rated lower than the pan, it's probably coated.
Skip "nonstick" pans unless they say "ceramic" and "made without PTFE." "PFOA-free" on its own usually means PTFE.
Don't take "granite" or "stone" at face value. It can mean porcelain enamel, like Granite Ware, or a speckled coating. Some enamel roasters are even sold as "nonstick" pans with no PTFE at all. Find out what the surface actually is.
Skip unbranded imported aluminum, especially pots labeled Hindalium or Indalium. The FDA has warned that some imported aluminum, brass and aluminum-alloy cookware can leach lead into food.
For enamel, look for a maker that says its enamel is free of lead and cadmium, and retire the pan once it chips.
The MAHA angle: Washington is pulling back, and the states are moving
The MAHA Commission's 2025 assessment called for more study of PFAS, along with bisphenols and phthalates, according to a summary by the law firm Beveridge & Diamond. It stopped short of proposing limits, and no federal rule restricts PFAS in cookware.
The clearest federal action on PFAS has been in drinking water, and it's moving backward. In April 2024, the EPA set the first national limits on six PFAS in tap water, including GenX. In May 2026, the agency formally proposed rescinding the limits for four of them, GenX included, saying the earlier rule hadn't followed the steps the law requires. It proposed keeping the limits for PFOA and PFOS but letting water systems apply for two more years, until 2031, to meet them. Public comments closed in July.

Here's why GenX belongs in a cookware guide. It's one of the compounds produced at Chemours' Fayetteville Works plant in North Carolina during the manufacture of Teflon, according to the North Carolina Coastal Federation. In 2017, it turned up in the drinking water of the Cape Fear Public Utility Authority, which serves more than 300,000 people, and about 1.6 million people get their water from the Cape Fear River. In July 2026, a lawsuit brought by more than 2,600 neighbors over PFAS from the plant settled out of court, and the EPA has proposed a separate settlement with Chemours, which denies violating the laws involved.
Your roasting pan didn't contaminate the Cape Fear. But a nonstick coating has a history before it reaches your kitchen, and a pan with no coating doesn't.
The states have done more. Minnesota banned cookware with intentionally added PFAS in 2025, and Rhode Island's ban begins in 2027, according to the law firm Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner. Colorado, Maine and Vermont have banned intentionally added PFAS in cookware since Jan. 1, 2026, and Connecticut now requires disclosure, with a ban starting in 2028. If you live in one of those states, PTFE-coated roasters are already off the shelf or on their way out. Everywhere else, catching the coated rack is up to you.
How we chose
No coating on the pan or the rack, with one clearly labeled exception for families who want a nonstick pan.
Room for a real turkey, ideally 16 pounds or more.
Stovetop-safe construction where possible, so you can make gravy right in the pan.
Clear materials from the maker or seller, including the rack.
A range of prices, from under $50 to a pan you'll hand down.
We didn't lab-test these pans. Our picks rely on manufacturer and retailer specs, owner reviews and published research. Prices are what we found when we checked in November 2026, and holiday sales move them often.
Detailed reviews
OUR PICK
Made In Stainless Clad Roasting Pan

Photo: Made In
What touches your turkey: A 3-ply stainless clad pan, with its aluminum core sealed between layers of stainless steel, and a stainless steel wire rack.
Capacity: Made In says it fits a 24-pound turkey. The pan measures about 18½ by 12½ inches and 6 inches deep.
Why we picked it: It's the biggest and best-built pan on our list. It's heat safe to 600°F, so a hot start or a few minutes under the broiler is no problem, and the aluminum core spreads heat evenly when you set the pan across two burners for gravy. It was $164.99, down from $199, when we checked.
Things to know:
It's heavy: 8.6 pounds for the pan, 10 with the rack.
This pan is made in Thailand, though some other Made In cookware is made in Italy and the U.S.
At more than 18 inches long, it won't fit every oven. Measure first.
Best for: Big holiday birds and families who'll use it for decades.
BEST VALUE
Cuisinart MultiClad Pro 16"

Photo: Cuisinart
What touches your turkey: A triple-ply stainless steel pan with an aluminum core, and a solid stainless steel rack.
Capacity: Owners report fitting a 22-pound turkey. With handles, it measures about 19 by 12 inches, which is why Crate & Barrel lists it as a 19-inch pan. It's the same 16-inch roaster.
Why we picked it: It has the same clad construction as pricier pans for less money. It's induction-ready, so it works on any stovetop for gravy, it's dishwasher-safe, and Cuisinart backs it with a lifetime warranty. It was $119.95 on sale at Crate & Barrel and $159.99 at Target when we checked.
Things to know:
It sells out before the holidays. It was out of stock at Walmart when we checked, so order soon.
Best for: Most families.
BUDGET PICK
Cuisinart Chef's Classic 16"

Photo: Cuisinart
What touches your turkey: A stainless steel pan with a solid stainless steel rack.
Capacity: A standard 16-inch roaster, comfortable for a turkey up to about 16 pounds.
Why we picked it: It's plain stainless steel at a lower price. It's oven safe to 500°F, and it was $79.99 on sale at Kohl's, down from $129.99, when we checked.
Things to know:
Without a clad aluminum core, it heats less evenly on the stovetop, so stir gravy often.
Kohl's stock varies by location, so check delivery before you count on it.
Best for: A coating-free roaster for once-a-year use.
CHEAPEST PICK
Granite Ware 19" Covered Oval Roaster

Photo: Granite Ware
What touches your turkey: Porcelain enamel fused to carbon steel, the speckled roaster many of our grandmothers used. Target's listing says it has no PFOA or PTFE.
Capacity: Up to a 20-pound bird with the lid off, or 16 pounds with the lid on.
Why we picked it: It's the least expensive way to roast a full-size turkey without a nonstick coating, and it comes with a lid, which keeps meat moist without an oven bag or foil. It was $45.99 at Target when we checked.
Things to know:
Enamel can chip if it's banged, and you shouldn't cook in a chipped pan.
Granite Ware doesn't publish lead or cadmium testing for its enamel.
Target lists it as made in the USA or imported, so check the box if that matters to you.
It's thin, so it isn't for stovetop gravy, and the basic version has no rack. Walmart sells a version with an oval rack.
Don't confuse it with the 15-inch Granite Ware oval, which holds only about 10 pounds.
Best for: Tight budgets and covered, moist roasting.
IF YOU WANT A NONSTICK PAN
Caraway Roasting Pan
What touches your turkey: Caraway's proprietary ceramic nonstick coating, which it says is free of PTFE, PFOA, PFAS, lead and cadmium, and a removable stainless steel wire rack.
Capacity: Caraway lists the pan at 16 by 13 inches and says it has room for a Thanksgiving turkey, though it doesn't give a weight limit. That size matches Williams-Sonoma's minimum for a 20-pound bird.
Why we picked it: If your family won't give up nonstick pans, this keeps PTFE out of a pan that sits in the oven for hours, and unlike many nonstick roasters, its rack is plain stainless steel. It's oven safe to 550°F.
Things to know:
It's still a coating, and coatings wear. Plan to replace it once food starts to stick, and skip metal utensils and abrasive scrubbers.
Caraway doesn't publish the coating's full formula, and its product page doesn't say what the pan body is made of.
The page didn't show a clear price when we checked, so compare before you buy.
Best for: Families who want easy cleanup and accept replacing the pan sooner.
What to avoid in a roasting pan
Nonstick roasters and nonstick racks. Check the rack separately. A low temperature limit on the rack is a red flag.
High-heat starts and broiling in nonstick pans. They can push a coated pan toward the temperature where PTFE breaks down.
Unbranded imported aluminum, especially pots labeled Hindalium or Indalium, which are on the FDA's lead warning list.
Chipped enamel. Retire it.
Hot food in plastic. Skip the oven bag if you can, and separate gravy in glass.
Foil on acidic glazes. Put parchment between the food and the foil.
Roasting tips for a coating-free pan

Use a thermometer, not the clock. The USDA says a whole turkey is safe at 165°F in the thickest part of the thigh, wing and breast, and recommends letting it stand 20 minutes before carving.
No rack? Use vegetables. A bed of thick-cut onions, carrots and celery lifts the bird and flavors the drippings.
Make gravy in the pan. Set a clad pan across two burners and scrape up the browned bits with broth or wine.
Use parchment, not spray, if you're worried about sticking, and between the bird and any foil.
Soak, don't scrub. Fill the pan with hot water and a spoonful of baking soda after dinner. Stuck-on bits lift off by morning.
FAQs
Is a nonstick roasting pan safe for turkey?
At 325°F, a nonstick pan is well below the roughly 500°F point where PTFE starts to break down. The concerns are scratched coatings shedding particles into drippings, high-heat starts and broiling, and the fact that PTFE is a PFAS. A stainless steel or enamel roaster avoids all three.
Is a ceramic roasting pan like Caraway non-toxic?
Caraway says its coating is free of PTFE, PFOA, PFAS, lead and cadmium, which makes it a better choice than a PTFE nonstick coating. But it's still a coating that wears, and Caraway doesn't publish its full formula. Plain stainless steel or enamel is simpler.
Is an enamel roasting pan like Granite Ware safe?
Porcelain enamel on steel has no PTFE coating and is a long-standing budget option. Ask the maker about lead and cadmium testing, which Granite Ware doesn't publish, and replace the pan if the enamel chips.
Can I roast a turkey in a disposable aluminum pan?
Many people do. They're flimsy under a heavy bird, Williams-Sonoma advises doubling them, and aluminum moves into food more with fat, acid and heat. A stainless steel or enamel roaster is sturdier and lasts for decades.
Are turkey oven bags safe?
Reynolds says its bags are an FDA-compliant nylon rated to 400°F. Germany's risk assessment agency has found that small molecules migrate from nylon-family kitchen utensils into hot food and advised keeping that contact brief. No one has published a similar study of oven bags that we could find. A lidded roaster gets you moist meat without the plastic.
What size roasting pan do I need for a 20-pound turkey?
Look for a pan at least 16 by 13 inches, or an 18-inch pan. Among our picks, the Made In, the Cuisinart MultiClad Pro and the Granite Ware 19" with the lid off all fit a 20-pound bird.
The bottom line
Your turkey spends hours in its pan with fat, salt and acid, so skip nonstick coatings on the pan and the rack.
Some stainless roasters ship with a PTFE-coated rack. Check before you buy.
"PFOA-free" means almost nothing. Nearly every nonstick pan has been PFOA-free for a decade.
Cut the hot plastic and foil, too: a lid instead of an oven bag, parchment under foil, and glass for the gravy.
The Made In is our top pick, the Cuisinart MultiClad Pro is the best value, and the $46 Granite Ware 19" is the cheapest way to roast with no coating.
Washington is moving to drop its limit on GenX, a chemical tied to Teflon manufacturing, while the states ban PFAS cookware. Order soon; the good pans sell out before Thanksgiving.
More from Healthy Again
Sources
Healthy, Again. is health news, not medical advice. Talk to your doctor about any health concern.