We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page.

Earlywood hardwood cooking utensils
GIR silicone spatula set
OXO stainless steel turner
Photos: Earlywood, GIR, OXO

Black plastic spatulas got a bad name in 2024, when a study found flame retardants in some of them. The study's math overstated the risk, but researchers still say not to leave black plastic sitting in hot oil. The easy fix is to cook with wood, stainless steel or silicone. Our top pick is Earlywood's hardwood starter set. For a flexible spatula, get GIR's silicone set. For cast iron and stainless pans, a steel turner is hard to beat.

How we vetted these picks

✓ We looked at what touches hot food: the head of each tool, not just the handle.

✓ Solid wood, stainless steel or platinum-cured silicone only. No black plastic or nylon.

✓ We didn't lab-test. Picks rely on maker specs, retailer listings and published research.

Our picks

Earlywood hardwood flat sautes, scraper and spreader on marble
OUR PICK

Earlywood The Essentials (4-Piece Set)

Two flat sautes, a scraper and a spreader, each made of solid hardwood.

Touches your food: solid hardwood

GIR silicone spatula, flip and spoonula set
BEST SILICONE

GIR 3-Piece Ultimate Tool Set

A spatula, flip and spoonula, each a single seamless piece of platinum-cured silicone.

Touches your food: platinum-cured silicone

OXO stainless steel slotted turner
BEST STAINLESS

OXO SoftWorks Stainless Steel Turner

A cheap, thin stainless steel turner that slides under food and can't melt.

Touches your food: stainless steel (plastic handle)

What's wrong with black plastic utensils?

Some black plastic is made from recycled material, and chemicals from its first life can come along for the ride.

Flame retardants turned up in some. In a 2024 study in the journal Chemosphere, researchers screened 203 black plastic household products, including kitchen utensils, and found high levels of flame retardants in 17. Fourteen contained decaBDE, which the EPA banned in 2021, Scientific American reported.

The math overstated the risk. The authors compared their exposure estimate with the EPA's safety threshold but miscalculated the threshold by a factor of 10. Corrected, the estimated exposure was about a tenth of the EPA's reference dose, not close to it. The journal issued a second correction in 2025, Retraction Watch reported.

Heat is still the concern. Researchers quoted by Scientific American advised against leaving black plastic utensils in hot pans, since hot oil can pull chemicals out, and suggested replacing damaged ones. Our flame retardants explainer covers what the science links them to.

Who's regulating plastic utensils?

The EPA banned most uses of decaBDE in 2021, but chemicals already in circulation can come back in recycled plastic. That's how a banned flame retardant can turn up in a new spatula.

For now, the simplest protection is choosing utensils that aren't plastic at all for anything that touches hot food.

How we chose

We started with what touches hot food, then looked at how each tool handles different pans, price and care.

  • No black plastic or nylon on the part that touches food.

  • One material per head. Solid wood, stainless steel or silicone, with no coatings.

  • Clear disclosure. Where a maker leaves something out, like a core material or finish, we say so.

  • Tools for different pans, from nonstick to cast iron.

We didn't lab-test these utensils. Our picks rely on maker specs, retailer listings and published research. Prices are from the makers' sites or retailers when we checked and can change.

The best non-toxic kitchen utensils

OUR PICK

Earlywood The Essentials (4-Piece Set)

Earlywood hardwood flat sautes, scraper and spreader on marble

Photo: Earlywood

What touches your food: Hardwood, in your choice of jatoba, ebony, maple or bloodwood combinations, according to Earlywood. The page doesn't say what finish the utensils get.

Why we picked it: There's nothing here to melt or shed plastic. The thin, flat edges scrape up browned bits, flip eggs and stir, and Earlywood says the set works as well in cast iron as in nonstick pans.

Things to know:

  • Flat sautes don't scoop liquid. You'll still want a spoon or ladle for soup.

  • Hand-wash wood utensils and dry them right away. Dishwashers crack them.

  • Earlywood doesn't list its finish on the product page.

Best for: Everyday cooking in any pan, and anyone replacing a drawer of black plastic.

BEST SILICONE

GIR 3-Piece Ultimate Tool Set

GIR silicone spatula, flip and spoonula set

Photo: GIR

What touches your food: Platinum-cured silicone over what GIR calls a proprietary inner core, according to GIR, which says the tools are free of BPA and BPS and heat-resistant to 425°F.

Why we picked it: Silicone bends to scrape bowls and pans clean, which wood can't do. These are one piece with no seams for food to hide in, and they go in the dishwasher.

Things to know:

  • GIR doesn't say what the inner core is made of.

  • Keep it under 425°F. Don't leave it resting on a hot pan or burner.

  • Silicone is synthetic. It's more heat-stable than plastic, but it isn't wood or steel.

Best for: Baking, scrambled eggs and scraping every last bit out of a bowl.

BEST STAINLESS

OXO SoftWorks Stainless Steel Turner

OXO stainless steel slotted turner

Photo: OXO

What touches your food: A stainless steel head on a plastic handle, according to the Walmart listing. The handle stays out of the food.

Why we picked it: Steel is the toughest choice for cast iron and stainless pans. It handles high heat, gets under a crust and goes in the dishwasher.

Things to know:

  • The handle is plastic. It doesn't touch food, but don't rest it on the pan's edge.

  • Don't use it on nonstick or enameled pans, which it can scratch.

  • It's a single turner, not a set.

Best for: Searing, smash burgers and anyone cooking in cast iron or stainless steel.

What to avoid

  • Black plastic utensils, especially old, chipped or melted ones.

  • Plastic or nylon tools left resting in a hot pan.

  • Painted or lacquered wood, which can flake into food.

  • Cracked wooden spoons, which can trap food and moisture.

How to switch without overspending

  • Replace what touches hot food first: spatulas, turners and stirring spoons.

  • Keep plastic for cold jobs, like tossing salad, until it wears out.

  • Oil wood utensils now and then with the same oil you use on a wood cutting board.

  • Don't leave any utensil sitting in a hot pan.

FAQs

Are black plastic utensils toxic?

Some contain flame retardants, a 2024 study found, but its math overstated the risk. Researchers still advise against leaving them in hot oil and suggest replacing damaged ones.

Was the black plastic spatula study wrong?

Its exposure math was off by a factor of 10, and the journal has corrected it twice. The finding that some black plastic products contain flame retardants still stands.

Are silicone utensils safe?

Platinum-cured silicone is more heat-stable than plastic and isn't made from recycled electronics plastic. Stay under the maker's heat rating.

Are wooden utensils sanitary?

Yes, if you wash them by hand and let them dry completely. Replace them if they crack.

What utensils should I use on cast iron?

Wood or stainless steel. Both handle high heat, and steel can scrape off stuck-on food without damaging the pan.

The bottom line

  • A 2024 study found flame retardants in some black plastic utensils, but a math error overstated the risk.

  • Researchers still advise against leaving black plastic in hot oil.

  • Wood, stainless steel and silicone are simple swaps. Earlywood's hardwood set is our pick.

  • Replace the tools that touch hot food first.

More from Healthy Again

Sources

Healthy, Again. is health news, not medical advice. Talk to your doctor about any health concern.