In a survey at one New York City pediatric practice, 1 in 5 parents who used formula were feeding their babies formula imported from Europe, most often Holle or HiPP. They told researchers they believed European formula had better ingredients. On the points parents care about most, Europe's rules back them up. Europe limits the sugars allowed in standard formula, has required DHA since 2020, caps pesticides in formula and baby food at a level close to zero and sets legally binding limits for lead. The US is only now starting its first overhaul of formula nutrient rules in nearly 30 years. Here's what's different, how to buy European formula safely and what the MAHA (Make America Healthy Again) movement wants changed.
How we reported this guide
✓ Every claim links to the law, study or agency behind it.
✓ We say when research shows a link rather than proof.
✓ We didn't test any formula. This guide compares published rules, government testing and peer-reviewed studies.
Table of Contents
Why are American parents buying European formula?
The trend spread parent to parent. Only 8% of the parents in the New York survey heard about European formula from their pediatrician. By 2019, one Facebook group for HiPP and Holle users had 13,000 members. During the 2022 formula shortage, the FDA's Operation Fly Formula let foreign makers sell formula in the US for the first time.
Some of those brands stayed. Kendamil, made in England, is now sold at Target. Australia's Bubs won permanent authorization to sell in the US in September 2026. The two most popular imports, Germany's HiPP and Holle, are still bought mostly from online sellers.
What's different in European formula?
Both the EU and the US set minimum and maximum amounts for dozens of nutrients. Europe goes further on three things parents worry about: sugars, DHA and contaminants.
SUGARS
Europe limits the sugars in standard formula
Breast milk's natural sugar is lactose. EU rules say standard formula made from cow's or goat's milk must contain at least 4.5 grams of lactose per 100 calories. Table sugar is allowed only in formulas made from broken-down, or hydrolyzed, protein, and then only up to 20% of the carbohydrates. Glucose syrup, the same thing Americans call corn syrup solids, is allowed only in small amounts.
US rules set no lactose minimum and allow both table sugar and corn syrup solids, a UK nutrition charity's comparison found. Corn syrup shows up mostly in "sensitive," "gentle" and "comfort" formulas, which made up about half of US formula sales by 2022, Undark reported.
That matters because of one large study. Among about 15,000 babies in California's WIC nutrition program, those given lactose-reduced formula made with corn syrup solids had a 10% higher risk of obesity at age 2. A 2024 follow-up by the same team found a 5% higher risk after accounting for breastfeeding and other specialty formulas.
How strong is the evidence: The WIC studies are observational, so they show a link, not proof. But they're one reason many parents want lactose as the main sugar, which European rules require. Some babies who can't digest lactose do need a lactose-free formula.
DHA
Europe requires DHA. The US still doesn't
DHA is an omega-3 fat found in breast milk that helps build a baby's brain and eyes. The EU made it mandatory in all infant formula in February 2020. The US still doesn't require it, though many US formulas add it. In October 2026, more than six years after Europe acted, the FDA asked the public whether it should require DHA, ARA and L-carnitine.
PESTICIDES
Europe's pesticide limit is close to zero
EU law says infant formula and baby food can't contain more than 0.01 mg/kg of any single pesticide, or 10 parts per billion, and it bans some pesticides outright on crops grown for baby food. When the rule was written, that was about the lowest level labs could detect.
The US has no federal limits written for chemical contaminants in baby food. In an Environmental Working Group analysis, 22 of 58 conventional US baby foods had at least one pesticide residue, while the organic samples had none.
HEAVY METALS
Europe's limits are law. America's are advice
The EU sets legally binding limits for lead in powdered formula and baby food: 0.020 mg/kg, or 20 parts per billion. It also caps inorganic arsenic in baby food and in rice meant for baby food.
The US has no legal limit for heavy metals in formula. The FDA tested more than 300 formulas sold in the US and found most had undetectable or very low levels, and it says it's working toward limits. For baby food, the FDA's lead levels of 10 ppb for most foods are "action levels," guidance that companies aren't legally bound to meet. Its cadmium levels were only proposed in October 2026. California went further on its own, requiring baby food makers to test for heavy metals and post the results, though the law doesn't cover formula.
Europe vs. the US at a glance
Europe | United States | |
|---|---|---|
Lactose in standard formula | At least 4.5 g per 100 calories | No minimum |
Table sugar in standard formula | Not allowed | Allowed |
Corn syrup (glucose syrup) | Small amounts only | Allowed, common in "sensitive" formulas |
DHA | Required since 2020 | Optional |
Pesticides in formula and baby food | No more than 0.01 mg/kg each | No baby-food-specific limit |
Lead in formula | Legal limit, 20 ppb | No limit |
Lead in baby food | Legal limit, 20 ppb | Voluntary guidance, 10 ppb for most foods |
Is European baby food different too?
The same near-zero pesticide limit covers European jars, pouches and cereals. EU rules also cap added sugars in cereal-based baby foods and allow only small amounts of salt.

Some US brands now sell themselves on those rules. Little Spoon says it tests for more than 500 contaminants and holds heavy metals to the limits Europe requires.
Is European formula safe to feed your baby?
The formula itself is made to EU rules that are stricter than America's on sugars, DHA and contaminants. When researchers checked 16 European formulas popular with US parents, 15 met every FDA nutrient requirement. The problems they found were mostly with labels, not with what was in the can. Brands made to European and Australian recipes, like Kendamil and Bubs, have since passed FDA review. And the FDA has extended its policy that lets parents import formula for their own use.
If you import HiPP, Holle or another brand, the risks are practical ones. Watch for four things:
Instructions and scoops. Labels may not be in English, and scoop sizes differ, so make sure you know how to mix a bottle correctly.
Stage and iron. European formulas come in stages, and Stage 1 formulas tend to contain less iron. Ask your pediatrician whether your baby needs more after 6 months.
The seller. Third-party sellers aren't regulated, and formula can be stored or shipped badly. Buy from an established importer.
Recalls. US recall notices may not reach you. Sign up for alerts from the maker.
Is the FDA catching up?
Formula is one of Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s priorities. In March 2025 he launched Operation Stork Speed, a review of US formula that he said would bring "radical transparency" to its ingredients. FDA chief Marty Makary told Fox News that moms want formula without seed oils, corn syrup, added sugar or heavy metals, The Wall Street Journal reported.

So far, the changes are slow and partial:
Nutrients: In October 2026 the FDA proposed the first major update to formula nutrient rules in nearly 30 years. It covers four nutrients: iodine, manganese, vitamin A and vitamin D. Companies would get three years to comply.
DHA: Still optional. The FDA is only asking for comments on whether to require it.
Sugars: Rules on carbohydrates, where corn syrup would come in, are left for a later phase.
Contaminants: The FDA ran its largest-ever test of formula in April 2026, but there are still no legal limits for heavy metals in formula.
Seed oils: The Journal reported in February 2026 that the administration was unlikely to push them out of formula.
Transparency: The FDA posted a public list of every formula sold in the US in February 2026.
For parents, that means years before US rules match what Europe already requires.
The other side. Formula makers say seed oils are needed to mimic the fats in breast milk, and European formulas use them too. "Nutritionally, they both grow healthy babies just fine," University of Rochester researcher Bridget Young told Parents. And recalls happen on both sides of the Atlantic. A botulism outbreak tied to US brand ByHeart was linked to 48 confirmed or probable cases in babies. In Europe, Nestlé extended a recall to formula sold in 60 countries in early 2026 after a bacterial toxin was traced to an oil ingredient from a Chinese supplier.
How to choose a cleaner formula
EASIEST
European-style formula on a US shelf
Look for: Kendamil or Bubs.
You get a recipe made to European or Australian rules, with English instructions and US recall notices. Kendamil is sold at Target, and Bubs now has permanent US authorization.
IMPORTING
HiPP or Holle, bought carefully
Look for: An established importer, English mixing instructions and the right stage for your baby's age.
These are the brands most US parents import, and they're made under EU rules. Check the maker's site for recalls, and ask your pediatrician about iron once your baby is past 6 months.
US BRANDS
Check the first carbohydrate
Look for: Lactose as the main or only carbohydrate, the way European rules require.
Some US formulas qualify, including Similac Advance, Enfamil NeuroPro Infant and Bobbie, a US formula modeled on European recipes. If your baby is on a "sensitive" formula made with corn syrup solids, ask your pediatrician whether a lactose-based one would work. Some babies do need lactose-free formula.
STARTING SOLIDS
Vary the grains
Look for: Iron-fortified oat, barley or multigrain cereals, not just rice, and organic jars and pouches.
Rice takes up more arsenic than other grains, and the FDA advises parents to feed a variety of iron-fortified cereals. Organic baby foods had no pesticide residues in the EWG analysis. Brands sold in California must post their heavy metal test results, so check a maker's site before you buy.
FAQs
Is European baby formula better than American formula?
On several measures, Europe's rules are stricter. They limit sugars in standard formula, require DHA, cap pesticides near zero and set legal limits for lead. Many standard US formulas also use lactose and add DHA, so the biggest gap is with "sensitive" formulas made with corn syrup solids. Both use seed oils.
Is corn syrup banned in European baby formula?
Not entirely, but it's limited. EU rules allow small amounts of glucose syrup, and table sugar only in formulas made from hydrolyzed protein. US rules allow both.
Is it legal to buy HiPP or Holle in the US?
Yes, for your own family. The FDA lets parents import formula for personal use. HiPP and Holle aren't sold in US stores and haven't gone through FDA review, but they're made under EU rules. Kendamil and Bubs are sold in US stores.
Does European formula have less iron?
Often, especially Stage 1 formulas made for babies up to 6 months. Ask your pediatrician whether your baby needs more iron after 6 months.
What is Operation Stork Speed?
It's the HHS and FDA review of US infant formula launched in March 2025. So far it has produced a proposed update to four nutrient rules, the FDA's largest test of formula for contaminants and a public list of every formula sold in the US. Rules on DHA, sugars and heavy metal limits are still to come.
The bottom line
Europe's rules are stricter on sugars, DHA, pesticides and lead, and European formula is made to those rules.
The FDA's overhaul is just starting. The first rule covers four nutrients, DHA is still optional and corn syrup rules come later.
Buying European? Pick a brand sold in US stores, or import from an established seller with English instructions and the right stage.
Buying American? Choose a formula with lactose as the main sugar.
More from Healthy Again
Sources
Healthy, Again. is health news, not medical advice. Talk to your pediatrician before changing your baby's formula.