We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page.

Instant Pot Duo multi-cooker
360 Cookware stainless steel slow cooker
Lodge Essential Enamel Dutch oven
Photos: Instant Pot, 360 Cookware, Lodge

A slow cooker holds your dinner at a simmer for eight hours or more, so what the insert is made of matters. Many inserts are nonstick-coated aluminum, and traditional crocks are glazed stoneware. Our top pick is the Instant Pot Duo, which slow-cooks, pressure-cooks and sautés in an uncoated stainless steel pot. For a true slow cooker with no coating or glaze, the 360 Cookware set pairs a stainless steel pot with a heating base. If you'd rather not buy another appliance, an enameled Dutch oven in a low oven does the same job.

How we vetted these picks

✓ We looked at the insert, the lid and any seal that touches food or steam.

✓ Uncoated stainless steel inserts, or enamel with a published chemical disclosure. No nonstick coatings.

✓ We didn't lab-test. Picks rely on maker product pages, disclosures and food-safety guidance.

Our picks

Instant Pot Duo 6-quart multi-cooker
OUR PICK

Instant Pot Duo 6-Quart Multi-Cooker

Slow-cooks, pressure-cooks, sautés and makes rice in one uncoated stainless steel pot.

Touches your food: stainless steel pot, silicone sealing ring

360 Cookware 4-quart stainless steel slow cooker on its heating base
BEST SLOW COOKER

360 Cookware 4 Quart Slow Cooker Set

A heavy stainless steel pot on a slow-cooker base, with no coating and no glazed crock.

Touches your food: stainless steel

Lodge Essential Enamel Dutch oven in indigo
SLOW COOK IN THE OVEN

Lodge 7.5 Quart Essential Enamel Dutch Oven

A big enameled Dutch oven that braises low and slow in your oven, no new appliance needed.

Touches your food: porcelain enamel

What's in a typical slow cooker?

Most slow cookers and multi-cookers hold your food in one of two kinds of insert, and both deserve a closer look.

Many inserts are nonstick-coated aluminum. All-Clad sells a slow cooker with an aluminum insert, and Hamilton Beach sells a programmable slow cooker with a nonstick aluminum crock. Many nonstick coatings are PTFE, a member of the PFAS family, and coatings wear with use. Our PFAS explainer covers why we skip them.

Traditional crocks are glazed stoneware. Glazes can contain lead, and the FDA randomly tests ceramic food containers like crockpots, NPR reported in 2017. Crock-Pot's customer phone line said then that it uses no lead additive in its glazes, and the report concluded that mass-produced crocks are probably safe. We didn't find a current lead statement on a crock maker's website.

Old and chipped crocks carry more risk. The FDA advises extra caution with antique or damaged glazed pieces, and no amount of washing removes lead from a glaze. Our lead explainer covers where else it hides.

Slow cooker or multi-cooker?

A slow cooker does one thing. You load it in the morning, set the heat and come back to dinner. It's the simplest choice if that's all you want.

A multi-cooker does several. The Instant Pot can slow cook too, and it can pressure-cook a stew in a fraction of the time when you forget to start it in the morning. It also seals with a silicone ring, which a slow cooker doesn't need.

How we chose

We started with what touches your food, then looked at disclosure, price and how each one cooks.

  • No nonstick coatings. Stainless steel inserts, or enamel with a published chemical disclosure.

  • No glazed stoneware crocks, since we couldn't find a current lead statement from a crock maker.

  • Clear disclosure. Where a seal, a layer or a metal is part of the design, we say so.

  • A range of prices, from about $100 to over $400.

We didn't lab-test these cookers. Our picks rely on maker product pages and disclosures. Prices are from the makers' sites when we checked and can change.

The best non-toxic slow cookers

OUR PICK

Instant Pot Duo 6-Quart Multi-Cooker

Instant Pot Duo 6-quart multi-cooker

Photo: Instant Pot

What touches your food: An inner pot made of 18/8 stainless steel with a tri-ply bottom, according to Instant Pot, with no coating mentioned. The lid seals with a ring that Instant says is food-safe silicone.

Why we picked it: It replaces a slow cooker, a rice cooker and a pressure cooker, and the pot that holds your food is plain stainless steel. It's also the cheapest way here to slow cook without a coating.

Things to know:

  • Instant recommends replacing the sealing ring every 12 to 18 months, or every 6 to 12 months to avoid odors.

  • Instant also sells RIO models. Check the box: the RIO Chef Series pot is ceramic-coated aluminum, not stainless steel.

  • The stainless pot can stick more than nonstick. Sauté with a little fat and deglaze to lift browned bits.

Best for: Busy cooks who want slow cooking, pressure cooking and rice in one appliance.

BEST SLOW COOKER

360 Cookware 4 Quart Slow Cooker Set

360 Cookware 4-quart stainless steel slow cooker on its heating base

Photo: 360 Cookware

What touches your food: A stainless steel stockpot that 360 says lets you cook directly on stainless steel with no chemical nonstick coating. The set includes the pot, its cover and a heating base, and 360 says it's made in the USA.

Why we picked it: It's a classic set-it-and-leave-it slow cooker without a glazed crock or a coating. The pot also works on the stove, including induction, and in the oven up to 500°F, so you can brown meat in it first.

Things to know:

  • It's expensive, and 4 quarts is smaller than most slow cookers. 360 also sells a 6-quart set.

  • The base has a dial with four heat settings but no timer.

  • 360 recommends hand-washing, since harsh dishwasher detergent can damage the aluminum layer in the pot's construction.

Best for: Anyone who wants a dedicated slow cooker with nothing but stainless steel touching the food.

SLOW COOK IN THE OVEN

Lodge 7.5 Quart Essential Enamel Dutch Oven

Lodge Essential Enamel Dutch oven in indigo

Photo: Lodge

What touches your food: Porcelain-enameled cast iron, according to Lodge. Lodge's California chemical disclosure for enameled cast iron doesn't list lead. It does list cadmium compounds, with a note pointing to red and orange items.

Why we picked it: A covered Dutch oven in a low oven is the original slow cooker. This one holds as much as a big crock, and you can brown meat on the stove and move it straight to the oven.

Things to know:

  • Pick indigo, oyster or sandalwood rather than red or ruby, given the disclosure's note on red and orange items.

  • You'll be running your oven for hours, and it isn't portable like a plug-in cooker.

  • Our Dutch oven guide has more picks, including bare cast iron with no enamel at all.

Best for: Weekend braises and stews, for cooks who would rather not add another appliance.

How to slow cook safely

Slow cookers hold food warm for hours, so a few food-safety rules matter. These come from Colorado State University Extension.

  • Thaw meat and poultry first. Frozen pieces may not heat to a safe temperature quickly enough.

  • Fill it half to two-thirds full.

  • Start on high for the first hour when you're cooking meat or poultry, then switch to low.

  • Keep the lid on. Each peek drops the temperature 10 to 15 degrees.

  • Don't reheat leftovers in a slow cooker. Reheat them to 165°F on the stove or in the microwave first.

What to avoid

  • Nonstick-coated inserts, which are often PTFE over aluminum.

  • Vintage, chipped or crazed crocks, especially brightly colored ones.

  • Ceramic-coated inserts sold as PFAS-free. They skip PTFE, but the coating still wears with use.

  • An old sealing ring in a pressure cooker that has cracked or holds onto odors.

FAQs

Are slow cookers non-toxic?

It depends on the insert. Many are nonstick-coated aluminum, and traditional crocks are glazed stoneware. A stainless steel insert avoids both.

Is the Instant Pot non-toxic?

The Instant Pot Duo's inner pot is 18/8 stainless steel, and Instant doesn't mention any coating. The lid seals with a food-safe silicone ring. Some other Instant models, like the RIO Chef Series, use ceramic-coated aluminum.

Do Crock-Pot crocks contain lead?

Crock-Pot's customer phone line said in 2017 that it uses no lead additive in its glazes, NPR reported, and the FDA randomly tests ceramic food containers. Be more careful with vintage or chipped crocks.

Can you slow cook in an Instant Pot?

Yes. Instant lists slow cook among the Duo's functions, along with pressure cook, sauté, steam, rice and yogurt.

Can you put frozen meat in a slow cooker?

No. Colorado State University Extension says to thaw meat and poultry completely first, since frozen pieces may not reach a safe temperature quickly enough.

The bottom line

  • Most slow cooker inserts are nonstick-coated aluminum or glazed stoneware.

  • The Instant Pot Duo slow-cooks in plain stainless steel. It's our pick.

  • The 360 Cookware set is a true slow cooker with nothing but stainless steel touching the food.

  • An enameled Dutch oven in a low oven works too. Thaw meat first and fill the pot half to two-thirds full.

More from Healthy Again

Sources

Healthy, Again. is health news, not medical advice. Talk to your doctor about any health concern.